Eyeliner is a staple in many makeup routines, but finding the perfect natural-looking liner can be a challenge. Say goodbye to harsh lines and hello to subtle definition! I've been on a quest to find the best natural-looking eyeliners, and these 11 products are the ultimate winners for achieving that coveted 'no-makeup' makeup look.
As a teenager, I was all about dramatic eye makeup, but now I prefer a more understated approach. And let's be honest, heavy eyeliner can be intimidating, especially for those with hooded eyes. So, I've been testing and swatching to find the perfect balance of definition and subtlety.
The Top Contenders:
Victoria Beckham Beauty Satin Kajal Liner in Cocoa: This liner is a standout for its versatility. It glides on smoothly, blends like a dream, and can be used for tightlining, soft wings, or defining lashes. The rich brown hue is perfect for a natural look, but it comes with a price tag to match.
Jones Road The Best Pencil in Brown: Created by the legendary Bobbi Brown, this pencil is a smudger's dream. It applies smoothly without dragging and can create soft definition around the eyes. The brown shade is ideal for a natural, 'no-makeup' look.
Victoria Beckham Beauty Instant Brightening Waterline Pencil: For a wide-eyed effect, this off-white liner is a game-changer. It brightens the eyes and makes them appear bigger, all while looking incredibly natural.
Beauty Pie Gel Eyeliner in Turkish Coffee: This gel liner is a long-lasting superstar. It's soft, easy to smudge, and won't budge once it sets. The only catch? You'll need a membership to access the best prices.
Charlotte Tilbury Rock 'n' Kohl in Barbarella Brown: If you want waterproof and indestructible, this is it. With an impressive wear time, it's gentle on sensitive eyes and blends easily. The brown shade is a natural choice.
Lisa Eldridge Seamless Glide Eye Pencil in Ground Coffee: For a luxurious experience, Lisa Eldridge's pencils are buttery soft and blendable. The Ground Coffee shade is perfect for natural definition along the waterline and lash line.
Glossier Boy Brow Arch: A brow pencil with a twist! Its fine nib delivers precise definition, making it perfect for subtle eyeliner looks. It's a versatile product that doubles as an eyeliner and brow pencil.
E.l.f. Smoky Kohl Eyeliner in Plum and Go: For those who want something softer than black, this burgundy liner is a great alternative. It defines the eyes while subtly enhancing eye color.
Rimmel Soft Kohl Kajal Eyeliner Pencil in Sable Brown: Rimmel offers an affordable option with a silky-soft formula. The Sable Brown shade is perfect for everyday, natural looks.
Ilia Clean Line Gel Eyeliner in Dusk: This retractable gel liner is precise and long-lasting. It sets quickly, so blend fast! But it's a great choice for those who want a smudge-proof option.
MAC Eye Kohl in Costa Riche: A favorite among makeup artists, this versatile liner comes in a deep brown shade with a matte finish. It's easy to blend and suits everyone, but it's often out of stock due to its popularity.
Application Tips:
- Tightlining: For a seamless, natural lash look, tightlining is key. It involves applying liner to the upper waterline, creating the illusion of thicker lashes. Soft kohl pencils are ideal for this technique.
- Color Choice: Brown eyeliners provide a softer look compared to black. Eyeliner pencils offer a more natural finish, while liquid liners create a crisp edge.
- Refreshing Trick: For a refreshed appearance, apply beige or off-white liner on the lower waterline to neutralize redness and fake a wide-awake look.
Our Testing Process:
We've swatched and tested countless eyeliners to find the most natural-looking options. From kohl pencils to gel liners, we've considered versatility and longevity to bring you the best of the best.
Why Trust Us?
At Who What Wear UK, we believe beauty is diverse. Our editors have extensive experience testing products and collaborating with experts to provide well-researched, inclusive, and relevant recommendations. We focus on formulas that deliver, whether they're budget-friendly or luxury splurges.
But here's where it gets controversial: Is natural-looking eyeliner truly achievable, or is it just a myth? Do you agree that these products strike the right balance, or do you prefer a bolder look? Share your thoughts in the comments below!
